Amanda was determined to keep her husband from being able to force her daughter to move to his house, so she set a trap for him.
Chapter 8 – setting the trap
Amanda put the wheels into motion to seduce her soon to be ex-husband. She and I, and one of the IT techs from Jill’s accounting firm made a trip to the lake house during the week. We stocked the liquor cabinet with a variety of drinks and mixers that she knew Jeff liked. Then we made sure the hot tub was ready to go. And most importantly, the IT guy set up motion activated cameras in several rooms. We had them in the master bedroom, the kitchen, and of course, in the area around the hot tub. They would work without Jessi having to do anything. All she had to do was make sure Jeff was in one of those rooms if any nasty shit happened. Two of the remote cameras were set up to send a video feed to Amanda’s computer if there was movement. So, we could watch the action. I was at Amanda’s house, and we had our own adult beverages in hand, ready to join the party remotely, and silently.
Jeff flew into town and Jessi drove to the airport to pick him up. It was mid-morning on Saturday. Jeff knew they’d be staying at the lake house, which surprised him since he knew Jill hated him. But Jessi explained that ‘Aunt Jill’ would do anything for her, so the lake house became available. Jessi had a few code words to use if she needed to text to Amanda during this weekend, since we knew she’d not be able to speak on the phone without spilling the beans on what was happening.
As soon as Jessi and Jeff arrived at the lake house, Jessi made a blender full of margaritas. She loved them and knew Jeff would too. They apparently had a second glass, then Jessi dragged Jeff outside to the hot tub area. We could see her pointing and gesturing to the hot tub, and then she just started stripping off her clothes. Jeff was shaking his head no. She was soon naked and ran inside to get towels for them. We could see him look down at his crotch, and then shake his head again, then start to undress. Amanda quickly exclaimed, “It worked! YES! That bastard is going to get naked with Jessi in the hot tub! That sick bastard is going to do it!”
We could see on Amanda’s computer screen that Jessi had a mug full of a drink and was stepping into the hot tub with her dad. He had gotten in earlier and actually looked quite uneasy. But after Jessi returned, she bent over and kissed him on the lips and said something that must have re-assured him, since his expression changed again. Jessi snuggled against Jeff, and they continued to talk and suck down the margaritas. I don’t know if Jessi was fixing some that were non-alcoholic for herself, but she seemed perfectly sober. Jeff, on the other hand, was looking a bit intoxicated.
They were on one end of the hot tub, sitting in a corner. The bubbles in the water kept us from seeing if anything was happening under the froth, but based on Jeff’s expression, it seemed like Jessi must have started her seduction. It was hard for me to watch, and I imagine even harder for Amanda.
It looked like Jessi had one leg draped over Jeff’s thigh. She was kissing his neck. I wish we could hear what was going on. This would have been a valuable porn tape if there was audio. I tried to banish that porn tape idea from my head, but all it did was give me a hard-on that was throbbing worse than before I thought it. Jessi was really getting into her role of seductress and she had him working on another drink in no time.
Then, we saw Jessi look towards the kitchen. She got out of the hot tub and trotted into the house. In just moments, the other two senior cheerleaders were in the view of the hot tub camera. They were chatting with Jeff, but you could tell he looked very uncomfortable. One by one, the girls left the hot tub camera, and came back with a mug of margarita. They were each now in a bikini. They all climbed into the hot tub and were drinking and laughing.
In no time, the two girls began shedding their bikinis. It looked like each was naked. They had shifted to the end of the tub where Jeff was, and Jessi was no longer there. I guessed she went to make another batch of drinks. The other girls just took it upon themselves to swarm poor Jeff. He never had a chance. They began kissing him and laughing as they splashed him and each other. Soon, one of the girls crawled into his lap. It looked like she was fucking him, but we could not tell due to the angle of the camera and the bubbles in the water. But if it looked inappropriate, that is all we cared about.
Jeff climbed out of the tub and helped the girls out too. Then they trotted into the kitchen where that camera took up the action. Jeff propped one naked girl up on the kitchen counter. He then dove between her legs and began eating her cunt. The expression on that girl’s face was priceless. It did not look like she had ever experienced anything like that before. We could see from the pleased expression on her face that she was enjoying it. When Jeff was done with her, he gestured for the other to girl to get on her knees and suck his cock. She did not look too experienced either. Jeff had to hold her head with his hands to guide her how to it.
We still had no idea where Jessi was during all this. Then, Amanda got a text from Jill. Jill said that there was a break-in at her lake house. The police had been called and she was in route, right now, driving to it. “Holy shit! Amanda, was this part of the plan? To call the cops on the house? Fuck me, this is becoming really serious”. Amanda calmly told me she wanted there to be a police report to go with the video. Amanda told me that Jill would not press charges, once she got there, but if the police were involved, it would keep Jeff from making any effort to take Jessi away from her.
“So, where the hell is Jessi?” I asked, totally confused. “She is driving home right now. The other girls came in another car, of course, and Jessi did not want to be there and be involved with the police”, Amanda stated calmly. “What about the video evidence, Amanda?” “Jill’s IT guy from her accounting firm got the same video feeds that we saw and is deleting any shot where Jessi’s face shows up. As far as the video footage will go, it will just be two high school girls in a hot tub with Jeff. It will not be criminal, but it damn sure will be enough to get him to back off”. Amanda was really proud of her trap, I could see.
About an hour later Jessi made it home. She was completely sober, thank goodness, and my suspicion that she made some margaritas with booze and some without was correct. She was a sharp kid. Another hour passed before Jill called in. The local cop came out to investigate the situation and Jeff was the one who answered the door. We could see on the video feed that he wore only a towel to answer the door, so he must have thought it was another girl. The cop was in the kitchen with him, and Jeff was gesturing wildly, as if he were innocent of any wrongdoing. Then, to top it off, Jill walked in, and started screaming at him. Now, I REALLY wish we had audio with this video feed. She put on quite an act of indignation.
It was all over in an hour. Jeff had to ride home with Jill, of all people, and the two cheerleaders left ahead of them. Jeff was taken to a hotel, and we did not hear anything more from him that weekend. Jill told him she had security footage which was how she knew he was fucking around with the cheerleaders. Jeff never even asked where Jessi was, according to Jill. I guess he was a bit too intoxicated to get past the fact that he had been caught messing with high school girls.
The evening ended with me, Amanda, Jill and Jessi all toasting to our brilliant success. It was fantastic the way it unfolded. Jessi did a masterful job of first seducing her dad, and then letting the other girls finish the job. The four of us were all very worked up by this time. These three ladies seemed bound and determined to get me in the same compromising position that we all watched Jeff get in. I was uneasy about this, but they soon turned my concerns into an erection.
I asked Jessi what she said to her dad to first start the conversation at the hot tub. Jessi told him that she had always wanted to be alone with him in the hot tub and now was the perfect time for them, since no one else was in the house. I asked her what her dad’s first response was, since he seemed a bit reluctant. Jessi said he asked her if she was on the pill. When she assured him she was, he changed his mind and decided to play with her. I could not believe it. He asked if she was safe to fuck! Geez. What a pervert! Jessi then told us she had specifically told her dad that she wanted him to fill her pussy with “Daddy cum”. Damn. Jessi was a hell of a temptress.
Jessi continued describing the scene in the hot tub. She had gotten naked and soon her dad was too. She kissed him and found his erect shaft hidden by the bubbles in the hot tub. Her fingers began lightly stroking him. She played with his ball sack, that was loose and dangling between his legs in the hot water. She told us she whispered in his ear that she wanted him inside her. That must have been about the time, in the video, where we could see her leg draped over his thigh.
Before she took it further, Jessi said she heard the other two cheerleaders, who had just arrived. She never had her father actually inside her cunt. Amanda, who had been sitting there, totally silent during Jessi’s re-telling of the event, burst out and said, “Thank God!”. It was a huge relief that her daughter had not committed incest with Jeff. We all looked at Amanda, then laughed, knowing that she still had a blind spot about her incest with her daughter. We all once again toasted to the good fortune and strategy that made the plan work.
Jill was the one who broke the ice about our own little situation. She asked “Hey, are we just going to rehash the lake house story all night, or are we gonna take advantage of your landlord and fuck his brains out?” Jessi said, “My vote is the fuck the shit out of Frank”. I eagerly held my hand up and “seconded” that vote.
The four of us quickly stripped down and were naked within moments. We moved from the couch to that new carpet I had installed before Amanda moved in. In the back of my mind, I knew we were going to add all kinds of sexual smells to this carpet, and I was envisioning Amanda rolling around on the floor, letting those sexual scents cover her skin. Oh my.
Amanda pushed me down on my back and kissed me deeply. Just before her mouth was planted on mine, she looked in my eyes, and said “thank you, for everything, Frank”. I was the one who should be thanking her, but I understood her sentiments. She kissed me deeply, as her fingers held my face. She was straddling my mid-section with her shaved cunt in contact with my belly. I could feel the tongue of someone else on my swollen cock. Amanda’s kiss, and then the sudden sucking of my cock, was an incredible combination of sensations. I don’t know why I never thought of having more than one woman at a time fuck me before Amanda and Jessi moved into my rent house. Oh yea, I was a nerdy landlord before they moved in. Now I am the luckiest landlord in the industry.
The four of us switched positions many times. Me watching Jill and Amanda make love was an incredibly erotic sight. Those two were made for lesbian sex and I would have paid admission to watch them. They went from deep kisses to 69 and began lapping at each other’s lovely snatches. Seeing them expertly eat each other out made me rock hard. Or was it because Jessi was sucking my dick? Oh well, I was as aroused as ever in my life.
I told the ladies I wanted them to get on their knees and line up. All three had their asses facing me. I told them I wanted to first do a taste comparison of their assholes. I began with Jill’s and buried my tongue as deep in her butthole as I could get it. I slurped and wiggled my tongue in and out of her delightful back door. Then I moved on to the next hole, which happened to be Amanda’s. Her asshole was already loose and tempting. I really wanted to plunge my cock into it right then but decided to continue my taste quest. Her asshole tasted delightful, as I already knew. She squirmed and shook her hips as my tongue played with her delicate hole. Yummy. And last, I moved behind Jessi. Her butthole was tiny compared with the two grown ladies’ shit holes. I don’t know if that was an age thing, or what, but she tasted ever bit as delicious as the two previous butt hole samples. I could not determine a winner.
Since they were all still lined up, I decided to start back at Jill’s and do a tightness test between the three cunts. I crawled behind Jill and eased my cock inside her lovely wet cunt. Jill let out a groan as I pushed into her. Oh my gawd, her cunt felt so tight and wonderful. Wow. I reluctantly pulled out and moved on to Amanda. Her cunt was dripping with her wetness, so I easily slipped inside her. What an incredible pussy she had. It was like fucking a lotion filled glove. OMG. I grabbed her hips and by habit, began to pound into her. Then I remembered I had a third cunt to compare, so I sadly pulled out of Amanda, and positioned my erection behind Jessi. She looked at me from over her shoulder and said “put it in me, Frank. Fuck my teenage cunt”. Oh, shit. What an invitation. I did as the lady requested. Her cunt was decidedly tighter than the older ladies, but all three were awesome. I could not believe I was sampling the fuck holes of these three extraordinary women.
My sampling of these lady’s holes did not end. I wanted to do a side-by-side comparison of each girl’s asshole. I crawled back to Jill and told her I was going to be inside her asshole for a comparison. She said, “do it, Frank. Fuck me any way you want to”. I took that as a “yes”. I eased into her, and pushed in until I had no daylight between my crotch and her butthole. I was buried in her. I stroked in and out several times but had to stop since I was so close to blowing my jizz.
I moved behind Amanda. I held my cock against her wrinkly opening, after having swabbed it with her cunt juice. It was wet enough, so I eased into her back door. She let out a continuous moan as I proceeded to get balls deep inside her. I stroked in and out of her too, but had to stop way too soon since I knew that if I kept going, the comparison between these three lovely ladies’ assholes would be incomplete. And nobody wants that.
Last in line to have her butthole sampled by my erect penis was the lovely and gracious teenager, Jessi. Her butthole had been sampled by me now more than once, so I could honestly declare it to be incredible. But, I could not let my personal past with her asshole interfere with my scientific comparison of the three anal openings, so the comparison had to continue. I announced to Jessi that she was next, and I positioned myself behind her. She was eager to get the comparison started since she felt her opening was probably the least used and abused of the three. She said “Wait, Frank, I need to lube up your prick before you shove it into me”. She flipped around and took my manhood into her mouth and slobbered all over it. She then looked up at me with her sexy face, and said “There, you are ready to proceed”. I proceeded.
I eased into Jessi’s very tight asshole. I slowly inched my way in, taking time for her sphincter muscles to relax to accommodate my prick. Soon I was buried inside her, just like I had been with Jill and Amanda. What a delightful comparison contest. I slowly eased out, and then back into her. She groaned and panted as I stroked in and out of her tight hole. I could feel her cunt muscles contracting below my cock. She was having an orgasm without me ever touching her clit. It must be wonderful to be young and responsive like that. Again, I was on the verge of exploding and I had to stop.
I kept myself shoved to the hilt inside Jessi, when I announced my findings to the three participants. I told all three that I was unable to reach a conclusion. Each asshole had its own feel and texture. And each had its own tightness. So, I would need to end this comparison because I was so desperate to “cum” to a conclusion. Having said that, I grabbed a fistful of Jessi’s hair and began pounding my dick in her backside. I roughly used her ass as hard as I could until I was nearly ready to climax. Both Jill and Amanda’s faces were now each resting on one of Jessi’s butt cheeks and they had a close-up view of me thrashing in and out of Jessi’s ass. I could stand the buildup no longer and shot a blast of cum inside Jessi’s bowels. I pulled out of her just in time to shoot another rope on her lower back. Amanda’s mouth was there to catch my jizz. She sucked my final rope of jizz out of my dick with her lips clamped firmly around my prick. She sucked every last drop from it.
She then offered my captured cum to Jill, who began kissing Amanda. I watched them swap my cum between them for several moments. It was the highlight of the comparison. I collapsed in exhaustion on the carpet with my prick still standing hard. Jessi took a turn to orally service me too, but I was too sensitive to stand it for long. Jessi then joined her mother in a cum swapping kiss too, as I watched in amazement. Those two were an incredible mother/daughter duo.
I was physically done. I crawled off to one side and let the three ladies have their way with each other from that point onward. I have never witnessed more tongue work, finger work and fisting as I saw that night. The ladies were very worked up, and it took many orgasms from each of them to finally satisfy them. It was a sight to remember.
It was an evening of celebratory debauchery. And the highlight of the evening was the confirmation that I still have my tenant with benefits, which included her daughter and her friend, Jill to add to the fun. Life does not get any better than this. On my drive home that night I bought a lottery ticket. I could not ignore my streak of good luck when it was staring me in the face. If that lottery tickets pays out, you can expect me to write another chapter of this saga. Keep your fingers crossed for me.