sexstories.com

Introduction:

Mr. Michaels has Sarah call Jenny while torturing her and fucking her. Jenny finds herself ensnared in the same trap that caught Sarah. Forced to decide, she submits as well leading to her first night with Mr. Michaels and sharing Sarah’s first lesbian sex.

Author's Note: I appreciate the continued support and readership. Positive votes are of course appreciated, mainly to make sure that people see the story and try it out. But I would really appreciate more comments. Good, bad or indifferent. Tell me what you think, what you like, what you would change, or suggestions on where you want the story to go. I will keep putting out chapters every few days until the full story is told. That much I promise.

Sarah called Jenny that night about the extra babysitting gig, letting her know it would only be for a couple of hours. Jenny agreed happily to join again. They talked for ten minutes about what to wear. Jenny laughed at how much fun she had teasing the old perv. Sarah agreed but knew her friend would feel differently one day soon.

She idly wondered if Mr. Michaels would make Jenny walk to his home naked at some point. Just the thought of the previous night sent shivered down her spine and excited her. She wondered if she would get the same thrill if he ordered her to make the naked run again. And would he want other outdoor sex? She admitted to herself that she like the feel of being exposed in public. The speculation made her pussy wet again and she spread her legs and stroked herself while they talked.

Jenny elected to go with a lace up crop top that she would leave loose so that it would show her cleavage and a little underboob. And she agreed to lend Sarah an open top that tied in the front just below the tits that would be perfect for her. Their best assets would be on full display. She even asked if Sarah thought they could get the tip up to $100 each. Sarah just laughed and went along with everything.

They got to his house on time and the outfits were definitely a hit being completely slutty. Sarah almost felt more naked than Saturday night on the golf course. “But not quite,” she laughed to herself. Jenny thanked Mr. Michaels for letting her come along and keep Sarah company. He agreed that Sarah probably appreciated a friend along and said it would be good to have a second babysitter that understood the routine in the event that Sarah might not be available. The girls knew that really he just wanted to have a second teenager parading around in skimpy clothes for him to ogle.

While they were still giving Billy his bath and Sarah asked Jenny to run up to get the ‘you now what’ since they would be short on time after getting Billy in bed. Jenny started to hop up to go run upstairs when Sarah leaned over and whispered, “maybe only $100 each? We just took so much. I don’t want him to notice.” Jenny started to argue, but Sarah pointed her eyes at Billy and Jenny finally shrugged and told her okay. She got back in about five minutes, in time for bedtime stories. When they plopped down on the couch in the den, Jenny handed her a $100 bill. Sarah chided her for not taking smaller bills and Jenny told her to stop worrying so much.

When the keys hit the bowl a short time later, they both jumped up to greet Mr. Michaels. They talked and flirted with him and Jenny found plenty of excuses to touch him and compliment him. She even stretched her arms up over her head with a fake yawn, but all the while knowing she would pull her shirt up enough to let her boobs pop out. She acted embarrassed, but took her time to get herself covered back up, giving him a lengthy view of her perfect teenage flesh.

Sure enough, they each got a crisp $100 tip. They laughed all the way home. Sarah reminded Jenny that Thursday would be the normal babysitting night, but she would understand if Jenny didn’t want to go with her twice in one week. Jenny told her get bent and would never dream of passing up such easy money.

Thursday night, they both wore babydolls. Technically they were lingerie, but they wore short shorts with them and played them off as tops. Everything went normally. To Sarah’s surprise, Jenny offered to go grab some of the secret cash while Sarah made them drinks. Mr. Michaels had wanted Sarah to try to find a way to get Jenny to do this anyway, so it made her job easy. She did wonder why Jenny seemed so eager to handle the task alone, but didn’t want to rock the boat.

Jenny came back with $200 for each of them, this time in smaller bills. Mr. Michaels came home at the usual time, a little tipsy, and flirted with the girls for almost twenty minutes, which resulted in another round of $100 tips for the two of them. Both left happy and giggling. Jenny thanked Sarah again on the way home that for letting her in on the best scam ever. Sarah went along but she knew the other shoe would drop soon.

+++++++++

With the week off of sex with Mr. Michaels, Sarah agreed to another date with Conner for Friday night. He picked her up and they went to a movie and expectantly had sex afterward. He didn’t have the house, so they had sex in his car. It ended up being a little uncomfortable, but still fun. She got on top first and then he came fucking her doggie style. He tried the ‘accidental' slip to stick it in her ass, but she stopped him. She told him that she didn’t like anal sex, but the truth was, she hadn’t gotten permission and Mr. Michaels had always been against anyone else touching her ass.

She made him eat her out after that and ground her pussy into his face. Once again, the persistent boy tried to get a finger in her ass and she had to stop him. By the time he had given her a nice orgasm, he had recovered, and she gave him a blow job. Afterward he laid back with a big smile on his face and complimented her on given the best head ever.

She woke on Saturday to a text from Mr. Michaels that he wanted a couple of hours at some point in the afternoon. She should just come by whenever she could get away without raising any questions. She left for ‘errands’ around 2:00 and headed to her rendezvous.

She found him waiting for her up in the bedroom. He had set up a massage table next to the bed with a triangular pillow sitting on it. She also saw rope, the nylon cuffs and some other toys sitting on the edge of the bed. He kissed her and started taking off her clothes. Once naked, he started putting the cuffs on her wrists and ankles and the collar around her neck. He explained that he wanted to play with her while she talked on the phone to Jenny. She should voice her concerns over how much money they had taken at some point in the conversation without letting on about anything else going on. Sarah sighed knowing it would be crazy hard to do, but resigned herself to following his instructions.

He started by taking two clothespins and after sucking on each nipple, he attached a clothespin to it with the pin being flat to her breast off to the side. They hurt instantly, even more than the nipple clamps. Then he told her to get on the table and helped her position herself face down with the pillow under her hips pushing her ass up in the air. It caused her tits to press into the table crushing her nipples held extended by the pins. She had to control her breathing right away and try not to think about how much it all hurt.

She hung her arms over the sides of the table, and he tied them tight to the legs of the table. She tested the restraints and confirmed that she couldn’t move her arms or torso at all. In fact, this position put even more pressure on her tits. He tied her legs spread about 12” apart and then tied each leg to a table leg. She couldn’t move either leg at all. He had her completely immobilized.

While she tested the leg restraints, he used her phone to dial Jenny and put it on the bed a few feet from her face. Jenny answered right away and Sarah tried to sound cheery and breezy.

“Why do I sound like I’m on speaker?”

Sarah thought quickly and said, “You are. I’m sorting laundry and need my hands free. I’m alone in the house. No worries.” Mr. Michaels started to rub her pussy and also rubbed lube into her ass.

“Great, anal too,” Sarah thought to herself. She tried to just concentrate on the small talk. Jenny described a cute outfit she had seen that morning in one of her favorite stores while Mr. Michaels grabbed something off the bed and started to rub it along her pussy. She didn’t see what item he had taken off the bed, but it felt egg shaped as he slowly pushed in into her vagina. Once placed, it started to vibrate.

“Wow, that sounds amazing. Did you find some shoes too?” She had to bite her lip while Jenny went on describe several different pairs. The vibrator sat right on her g-spot and she wanted to moan immediately. But at least it distracted her from thinking about her nipples. She realized Jenny had asked her a question.

“What?”

“I asked whether you thought I should get blue or black. You seem distracted.”

“Yeah, sorry, I was…um…trying to figure out if I needed to add fabric softener to this.” She tried to cover but hadn’t really heard anything Jenny had said. Mr. Michaels picked up a long string that attached five metal balls that were all about an inch and half in diameter and held them in front of her face. She recognized them as anal beads, but the size made her cringe. “Jenny, there is something I want to talk to you about. Something I need to talk to you about.” Mr. Michaels had his phone out and did something and the vibrator started a pattern of waves, going up and down in intensity.

“What’s up?”

“Um….It’s just that…” Sarah had so much trouble concentrating, she felt herself stumbling over her words. Her pussy started to leak. And Mr. Michaels moved toward her ass with the anal beads. “It’s just that I am worried about how much money we took this week.” He started to rub the first ball against her asshole.

“What’s the problem?” she said clearly a little irritated.

“It was a lot of money.” The first ball popped into her ass and she gulped at the pain as it passed into her. “I’m just worried. Don’t you think he might figure it out?” The second ball joined the first.

“You’re a worry wart. Listen, that old degenerate doesn’t have any idea how much money is in that drawer, and he doesn’t care.” The waves on the vibrator changed to a slow ramp up and then three intense pulses that lasted about 3 seconds each. Jenny changed to a conspiratorial tone, “Did you see the way his eyes bugged out when my top popped up? All he cares about is having his hot babysitters bouncing their tits in his face.” Another bead slowly entered. Her ass already felt full. And the vibrator really started driving her crazy. She could already feel the tickle of an orgasm forming.

“Um…but what could happen…um…if he does?” She needed Jenny to keep talking. She had trouble forming words. The fourth ball pushed the others deeper and wanted to come right back out. She had to clench to keep it in place. And the vibrator went to sets of pulses at different intensity, with each pulse getting progressively longer. Her hips started to grind. The vibrations were getting to her clit and the threat of her cumming became ever more serious.

“Look, he’s not going to find out. But even if he did, we could just accuse him of hitting on us and touching us if he says anything. I mean, it would be two against one. And who is going to believe an older guy wouldn’t touch a teenager inappropriately.” The fifth ball forced its way into her ass. Now her rectum felt uncomfortably full. She could sense her asshole winking trying to restrain the last one. She feared it would pop out. He pushed harder with his finger and they all moved in a little deeper. She actually groaned a little, but quickly covered it up by coughing for a minute.

“Sorry, took a drink and it went down the wrong pipe.” She coughed again intentionally so she could concentrate on stopping the orgasm that wanted to be let loose. Her pelvis went into a full involuntary grind trying to rub her clit. No other part of her body could move. She had an itch that she couldn’t scratch and she needed relief.

“Look sweetheart, it’s our time in the world. Old middle-aged guys are assumed to be pervs. Not that I want to do anything to Mr. Michaels, but if he says anything then we just let him know we are prepared to run to the cops.” Mr. Michaels had been rubbing her ass which only made everything more difficult. Finally, he mercifully turned the vibrator off and then pulled it out of her pussy. As it came out, she felt a tremor rip though her midsection. She had a small orgasm and had to clench her whole body not to make a noise.

“So are you good? Will you stop worrying about it?” Jenny continued when the silence stretched on.

“Um….yeah….yeah….I guess so. I just don’t want to get in trouble…..or cause problems” She struggled to get the words out without sounding strained. She needed another topic to get her talking. Mr. Michaels had gotten silently on the table and straddled her legs. She knew he would start fucking her at any moment.

“Let me ask you something else. Would you ever, you know, have anal sex?” She had no idea why she asked this. Maybe the five giant beads in her ass that were resting on her anal ring very anxious to come back out dominated her thoughts. But she needed something that Jenny could take the lead on. And Jenny loved to flaunt her more extensive sexual experience to Sarah. As she finished asking the question, Mr. Michaels started to slide his dick into her. The wedge-shaped pillow under her put her vagina in the perfect position for his entry.

“Ewww. What is this about?! Oh wait. Is this about Conner?!” she asked excitedly.

“Well, maybe. Okay look. He asked me if I would. I told him no, but now I’m like, should I?” Mr. Michaels took long slow strokes being very careful not to make any noise. Sarah’s whole body felt tortured. Each time he pushed fully into her and rolled up on her ass, he forced her tits to drag on the table, tweaking her nipples with more pain.

“Hell no. Well at least I wouldn’t recommend it. I told you I tried it once. With Ryan Daniels. Remember? We went out for like five weeks and we did it a couple of times and he tried to stick it in back there. It hurt like hell!! He got about halfway in and I was like ‘No fucking way. Get that thing out of me!’” Jenny rolled with laughter at her story. Mr. Michaels started to pull on the string of the anal beads and Sarah’s asshole stretched open. Right when Jenny had said ‘fucking’, the first bead pulled past the midway point and popped out. Sarah started cumming again and she her body started shaking. “I even bled a little. And it hurt for like three fucking days!” Jenny continued.

“That sounds awful!” Sarah eeked out in between spasms. Right then, the second bead started to exit. She bit her lip to keep from screaming out.

“So my advise is you tell that prick that there is no way he is taking your anal cherry. Save that for when you can get something really big. Like a car!” She and Sarah laughed, but Sarah’s laugh only covered her gasp as the third bead exited. Her legs trembled uncontrollably and she still felt the warm waves of orgasm wash over her.

“I guess your right. What should I tell him?” She didn’t want advice. She just wanted Jenny to keep talking. Mr. Michaels ground into her with each thrust and she feared losing all control.

“Well if it were me, I would just tell him it is front door only and if he doesn’t like it, he can find a real slut that wants his tiny pecker up her poop shoot. But I told you, I don’t know why you are even seeing that guy. He is so cocky and such a dipshit. You can definitely do better bitch.” As the fourth bead extricated itself, he also took one of her clothespins off. The sudden rush of blood made her right nipple throb.

“I guess so. What are you doing tonight?” She turned her face into the cushion of the table to try to stifle her moan. She desperately wanted him to end the call and just fuck her. She couldn’t take this crazy tease and she could hear suspicion growing in Jenny’s voice. Her side of the conversation made her sound so distracted. Her words were inconsistent and mostly rushed. And despite all of her efforts, Jenny couldn’t have missed the small grunts that had escaped.

“What do you mean? You know we are all going over to Samantha’s. You are going to be there, right?”

“Oh yeah. Stupid me. I’ll call you later. I want to get this last load out.” Right as she said it, he pulled out the last bead. Her asshole gapped open, made worse by him spreading her ass cheeks wide to inspect his work. She wanted to let go so badly.

“See ya slut!” Jenny said with the line going dead. Sarah let out a huge grunt and Mr. Michaels started slamming into her with loud slaps of their bodies colliding. He grabbed her shoulder with one hand for leverage and started fucking even harder. With his other, he pulled off the remaining clothespin. She screamed at both the pain and then the intense pleasure of his dick as he went into overdrive.

She screamed desperately, “Please may I cum MASTER!”. He grunted ascent and she had a giant orgasm while struggling to pull herself free with no success. Her clit became overly sensitive and she wanted it to stop even though every thrust brought waves of pleasure with it.

She strained so hard against her wrist cuffs she thought she might hurt herself. She both wanted it to stop and to never stop. Mr. Michaels finally groaned and thrust his hips forward with his hands on her back crushing her into the table. She could feel his hot jets flood her inner chamber. She panted shallowly while he gulped in several deep breaths. The pressure from his weight kept her absolutely locked in place. Finally, he rolled back and slid his cock out of her. She felt the seminal fluid gush out of her gapping vaginal opening while her whole lower half trembled and clenched. He slapped his wet dick on her ass checks and then hopped down.

“Not bad. You almost gave it away a couple of times. Nice job on the laundry comment though.” They both got a bad case of the giggles and laughed for a minute.

“Oh my god. I wanted to laugh out loud so bad as I said ‘get this last load out’ and you pulled the last one out of me. I really thought I would lose it there.” She kept giggling while he started releasing her limbs. Her numb arms hung limply when she could finally sit up. As feeling returned to them, she rubbed her poor molested tits. They were sore and her nipples were on fire. She got down on wabbly legs. And before he could yell at her or worse spank her, she drew her tongue through the pool of cum that had dripped out of her. Then she zombie walked to the bathroom and gulped down some water.

She came back and ran to Mr. Michaels and threw her arms around his midsection and hugged him and said, “Thank you for my orgasm sir. That was incredible.” She knew she was learning.

He kissed her and then told her to sit down on the bed. “I want to show you something before you go. But you need to keep this to yourself. Understood?”

“Yes sir.” He turned the TV on and started to play a video. It displayed the hidden camera view of the master bedroom. Jenny came into the room and it showed her dig out and place two $100 bills on the dresser and then three more that she counted out and stuck in her pants pocket before closing everything up and leaving. It jumped to the next time Jenny went up to get money. She counted out what looked like two stacks of $200 in smaller bills and then she counted out four $100 bills and stuck those in her pants pocket. She closed the drawer and grabbed the two original stacks and headed downstairs.

Sarah couldn’t believe it. She thought they were taking a lot, but Jenny stole double on top of it. If this weren’t a setup, she would be pissed. She ‘brought’ Jenny in on this and Jenny turned right around and basically cheated on her. She had double crossed Sarah and stole right out from under her nose. The careful instructions he had given her all suddenly made sense. He suspected that Jenny would cheat on the deal and steal more than her share. He set the trap and Jenny walked right into it. She wanted to kill Jenny.

“I said, you keep this to yourself. She has to decide for herself how she wants to respond. You can’t tip her off or we won’t know. I want you to promise. Now.”

Sarah fumed. She took a deep breath. “I promise sir.”

“You will bring Jenny with you on Thursday like normal. Don’t let on at all. You two can dress slutty again. Come over full of confidence. And then we will see how things play out. But never forget, you will not get in trouble no matter what happens. You have committed yourself to me with your decision and have lived up to your pledge. So I will protect you. She must make her own choice. If she chooses jail and legal consequences, then so be it. She is the one on video here taking the money.”

“Yes sir. I understand.” He sent her home and told her he would be in touch with any further instructions before Thursday. Sarah calmed down, but the betrayal left her pissed off.

+++++++++

Samantha’s ended up being fun despite Sarah’s distraction over what she had learned earlier in the day. She smiled and laughed with Jenny, but knowing what she had done put Sarah off. By the end of the night though, after getting a little drunk and high, Sarah put it out of her mind as worry for another time.

The rest of the week got back to a semblance of ‘normal’ apart from Sarah’s anxiety for Thursday night. She had stopped by the night before to receive some final instruction from Mr. Michaels. Mainly he wanted her to let things happen naturally. She remembered how shocked and disoriented that first night had left her. He did tell Sarah to address him normally in Jenny’s presence and to drop the ‘sir’ and ‘master’.

He reiterated that Jenny had to make her own decision. She had stolen money and committed a crime. She deserved to be punished. If she wanted to agree to an alternative punishment, then that would be up to her. But if she did choose to do so, she had to do so just as willingly and openly as Sarah had.

On Thursday afternoon, Sarah and Jenny planned their outfits. Jenny made a hundred suggestions and thrilled over the chance to tease the older man again. They finally decided on spaghetti strap tank tops and short shorts. The tops form fit tightly to the chests and showed off their nipples. They put on big t-shirts to leave the house and peeled them off in the car before they went inside.

They walked in excited, but that excitement soon evaporated as Mr. Michaels made it clear that he had a different agenda for the evening. He directed them to sit on the couch in the den. Once they were settled, he started to play videos on the TV. The first two showed Sarah taking money. The third showed Jenny counting out money with Sarah. And then there were two more showing Jenny counting out money and then also putting extra money into her pocket each time.

By the time the videos finished, both girls looked pale and scared. Sarah started by saying, “We are so sorry Mr. Michaels.”

Jenny jumped in saying, “We will give you the money back. We are sorry.”

“That’s it?! You’re sorry? You stole my money. And you think a simple ‘sorry’ will do it?!” His anger rose while he talked.

Jenny and Sarah both started to look more desperate. Sarah offered again, “We’ll give the money back. Please don’t get us in trouble.” Despite knowing her responses were simply an act, she couldn’t help but feel that same terror as the first time.

“Please don’t tell our parents,” Jenny pleaded.

Mr. Michaels paused and then started pacing back and forth in front of them. “Girls, I trusted you. What exactly do you expect from me? You have to be punished. I have no choice but to call the police.”

“We’ll give the money back!” Jenny said frantically.

“Yes! All of it. We’ll give you all the money back! Plus all the babysitting money.” Sarah offered right after. Jenny turned to look at Sarah, but thought better of commenting.

Mr. Michaels shook his head. “Girls, it’s not about the money. You stole. You have to pay a price for that. I’m sorry. You leave me no other option.”

“We will babysit for free. We’ll give you everything back and babysit for free on top!” Sarah almost screamed. She played her part perfectly.

“Please don’t tell my parents,” said Jenny again. Her true fear became evident. Either that or she didn’t realize how much trouble she could be in with the law.

“You have both committed a felony. That means jail time for both of you.”

“Jail?? You can’t mean that!” said Jenny first while Sarah said at the same time, “We can’t go to jail, please!” Both girls looked at each other realizing how much trouble they were really in and Jenny had tears running down her face.

“Just let us just pay you back.” Jenny said again.

“I’m sorry girls,” Mr. Michaels was shaking his head. “You give me no choice. I have to turn you in.”

The room filled with a long quiet moment while they all looked at each other. Then Sarah ripped her top off exposing her tits. “We’ll fuck you if you don’t turn us in.” Jenny looked possibly more surprised that Mr. Michaels appeared to be.

“What the fuck are you doing?” Jenny said looking only at Sarah. Any fear about her predicament replaced with utter shock at her friend’s actions.

Sarah sat there without hiding herself. “Jenny and I will both fuck you if you promise not to turn us in,” she stated looking resolute in her offer.

Jenny’s mouth dropped open completely flabbergasted. She turned fully to Sarah and asked, “Sarah, what are you doing?”

Sarah grabbed her arm and pulled her off the couch and walked her over to the side of the room. With their backs to Mr. Michaels, she said in a low voice, “We’re caught. I’m not fucking up my life and going to jail. If I have to have sex with him to keep him from calling the cops, then that is what I am going to do. With or without you,” she stated emphatically and unequivocally. She stared at her friend waiting for her to respond.

Jenny, still talking to Sarah with her back to Mr. Michaels, still in a low voice to keep the conversation as private possible, asked, “What the fuck are you talking about? Are you really going to fuck this guy?”

“Jenny, we committed a FELONY. We stole money. This could screw up my life. Our lives. Miss getting to go to college. Be stuck in a dead end job. If I have to fuck him to get him to let me go, then I’m going to fuck him. Do you really want to go to jail?”

“We won’t go to jail. My dad can fix this. What are you talking about? This is crazy.”

“HE HAS US ON VIDEO! We both stole his money. You even more than me. How the fuck is your dad going to get us out of this?! Do you really want to risk prison? Miss out on everything you have planned? Think about it!! How are you even going to tell your dad?”

The full repercussions started to hit Jenny. The thought of telling her father that she had stolen money and been caught started to dawn on her. She looked over her shoulder at Mr. Michaels. Sarah could see her commitment to her decision take hold onto Jenny. Jenny looked terrified and sick to her stomach.

“Listen Jenny, if you want to go down for this, then say so. I’m not. I have plans. I want to go to college and have a life. This is a small price to pay. For me. You make your own decision.” She still whispered, but the whisper had grown to a low roar. She suspected that Mr. Michaels could hear every word spoken. But even more, she knew that they stood in front of a camera capturing the whole conversation. Mr. Michaels had shown her exactly where to have a ‘private’ conversation with Jenny if she needed to.

Jenny continued to consider and weigh her options. Sarah’s willingness seemed to be getting to her. She knew Jenny’s alternative to face her father and the cops would be weighing heavily on her. But mainly her father. For all of his indulgence of his daughter’s spending habits and mediocre performance at school, he could also be an unforgiving prick and Jenny generally lived in fear of him.

“Come on. What are you going to do? Do you really want to face a felony charge?” Sarah prompted again.

Mr. Michaels just stood there while they debated.

Jenny looked back again and then she turned to Sarah, pleading “Are you sure? You really think we should have sex with him?”

Sarah sighed. “Look, I don’t want to any more than you do. But I am not throwing away my future instead of just having a little sex. Is that what you want? You’re supposed to go to ASU? You know there is no way they will let you in if you are convicted of committing a felony. Let alone what you dad will do. He’d probably make you stay at home even if he got you out of it somehow.”

That hit home. Sarah knew Jenny’s excitement over getting to move away and live out her college fantasies. Having to stay at home and miss out would be ultimate torture. She could see Jenny start to hyperventilate.

“Seriously. What the fuck does it matter if we have sex with this guy? You have fucked plenty of guys. How would this be any different? Why care? Let’s just get it over with and get to tomorrow.”

Again, Mr. Michaels only stood by and watched. Sarah hoped she had dutifully impressed him. She even hoped he might reward her for all her extra efforts in pushing Jenny to make the same decision she had.

Finally, Jenny seemed to concede to the situation. “I guess.”

They turned back to Mr. Michaels and Jenny concurred with Sarah’s earlier comment. “We will have sex with you if you agree to not turn us in.”

Mr. Michaels appeared to be considering. Sarah stood there topless next to Jenny. “Take your top off too,” he commanded. Jenny looked unsure, but with her friend already half naked and the fact that she had already flashed him once, she just shrugged and grabbed the hem of the top and pulled it up over her head. In one fluid motion, her beautiful breasts were suddenly on full display.

“If I agree to this, I want you both to understand, I am not looking for girls that I have to force to have sex with me. I need to know that you are doing so WILLINGLY. That you want to do this as an alternative to dealing with the law. An alternative that you two suggested. You both committed felonies and should go to jail for this.” He directed the girls to come back over and sit in front of him.

“Furthermore, I am a dominate person. I like to be fully in charge during sex. So I will consider it if you convince me that you would rather your punishment to be as my willing sexual submissives. Is that what you want?”

Sarah and Jenny looked at each other and then leaned in to talk quietly to each other. Sarah said, “I’ll do this if you will. I mean, I don’t want to fuck up my life, but you probably have more to lose. Are you sure you want to do this?”

“I guess I will if you will. My dad would kill me. Hell, he might disown me if I went to jail. I can’t do that. Are you sure you are okay with this?”

“I am if you are.”

“Okay. I am if you are too.”

They turned back. Jenny spoke first. “We guess we will do it.” Sarah nodded agreement.

Mr. Michaels frowned and shook his head with a sigh. “That’s not fucking good enough girls. I told you, you must be willing, not just compliant. This is bullshit. I’m just going to call the cops.” Mr. Michaels moved to pull out his phone and started dialing.

“No, Mr. Michaels, please!! We want to do it. We will. Please don’t call the cops,” pleaded Sarah for both of them.

He continued to frown and stare down at them. “You are going to have to prove it. I want both of you on video offering to sell yourselves to me, or this is over. I’m not going to fuck around and I’m not going to have you both coming back after we have sex saying I forced you or raped you or something. And don’t pretend that isn’t exactly what you would do!!”

“No really Mr. Michaels, we wouldn’t do that. We understand. We agree. You can make a video of us. Right Jenny?”

“Yeah. Okay. You can make a video and we will agree,” said Jenny in solidarity.

With that, Mr. Michaels sat down and ushered the girls to stand in front of him, eventually turning the phone in their direction. The girls looked at each other and then Sarah started. “We will fuck you if you agree not to turn us into the police…” Before she could finish the statement, Mr. Michaels put down the phone. “If you two bitches aren’t serious, we can be done now. Forget it. I’m calling the cops. You can deal with this bullshit yourselves. I’m done with this.” He lowered the phone and started dialing.

Jenny panicked. “Please don’t do that!!! Let us try again. Let me try.”

He turned to her, sighed, and finally started the video again, “We want to have sex with you. We will….be submissive or whatever. We want to do it. It is our choice to have sex with….” Again, Mr. Michaels stopped recording. He put it down and looked at both girls taking his time to let everything sink in.

“Girls, this is a mistake. Put your clothes back on and I am sure the cops will call you in the morning. I told you the only way I would even consider this is if you were willing to prostitute yourself. That means, I want each of you individually on video offering to fuck me for money. If you aren’t going to do that, then let’s just be done with this bullshit.”

“I’ll do it.” Sarah said confidently. “I promise I’ll get it right.” He put his phone back up on just her and she started, “Mr. Michaels, I want to be your whore. I will fuck you and suck your dick for money. I am offering myself to you willingly. I will be your slut to do with however you want. I promise, if you pay me, I will make your every fantasy come true.” She said it in a sexy voice and begged the camera with her eyes. She started pinching her nipples while she talked and molested her own breasts. She even reached down by the end and started rubbing her pussy.

Jenny’s mouth dropped. She had never seen Sarah act this way. Mr. Michaels turned to her. She had to make a choice and fully commit. Sarah clearly demonstrated her willingness. She closed her eyes and sighed. She really didn’t have much of a choice.

“Mr. Michaels, I’ve wanted you for a while. You are a sexy man. I want to be your whore. And I will be your whore, for money. I will have sex with you and do whatever you say. For money. I will be your prostitute.” She made herself look as sexual and submissive as she knew how. She tried to copy Sarah, since Sarah seemed to have given him what he wanted and Jenny did her best to match her efforts. She also ran her hands over her body and pinched her nipples and squeezed her tits for the camera.

Mr. Michaels turned off the video and put the phone down. He seemed to be considering the girls for a minute while they held their breath waiting for what he would say next.

“All right girls. I believe you and if that is what you want, I’ll forget the money and we will go upstairs and fuck. Last chance to back out. If we go upstairs, you are committed, understood?”

“Yes s….I am ready,” said Sarah. She almost screwed up. Addressing him as sir had become so ingrained. She had trouble not saying it.

“I’m ready too,” Jenny concurred. Both girls turned and started heading upstairs.

Once upstairs, Mr. Michaels took each girl and stood her in front of the bed next to each other. He started with Sarah and pulled her shorts and underwear down. She stood there completely naked. Then he turned to Jenny and did the same. He seemed surprised to see Jenny still had a full thick bush. She had trimmed the sides for a bikini, but it covered her pussy lips. Jenny couldn’t help but try to cover herself at his examination. He grabbed her hands and pulled them to her sides, making it clear that she should not move or cover herself. He stood back and examined his two nubile teens carefully.

“Very nice. You are both beautiful. Any man’s dream. Jenny, your eyes are hypnotizing. And Sarah, you have the face of an angel. Not to mention both of you have bodies to drool over.” Both girls blushed at his comments, but neither moved.

He approached Sarah first. He kissed her, groped her body, and then leaned down and sucked on her nipple and bit it. Sarah saw Jenny looking at her and moaned as he suckled on her breast. He moved over in front of Jenny and Sarah felt a small pang of jealousy watching him kiss and grope her body in the same manner. She watched him lightly trace his fingers over her soft skin and heard Jenny draw a sharp breath as his teeth sunk into her nipples, pulling on first one and then the other.

He stood between them and went back and forth kissing each one while he stroked each of their pussies, slowly inserted a finger and finger fucked them at the same time. He gave them a few minutes to enjoy his advances and start to respond. The girls each reached to hold onto him for support and both started moaning as his finger fucking got more aggressive.

He hooked his middle two fingers into each of them and started jerking his hand harder up and down. Sarah ground her hips in time with his hand enjoying the rising tempo when he suddenly pulled his hands out of both of them leaving them wanting more. He stuck his fingers into each of their mouths and made them suck the sticky juices off of them.

He told them simply to take his clothes off. Sarah moved instantly and started undoing buttons. Jenny took a second to recover, but imitated Sarah’s actions, working together. When Sarah started to take off the shirt, he told her to fold it neatly and put it on the chair. Jenny started on his belt and pants. She pulled the belt through the loops in one big motion and then helped him step out of the pants. She gathered up the pants and took both items to the chair and she dropped them on top of the folded shirt.

As she came back toward Mr. Michaels and he slapped her face. She jumped back in total shock. “Does that look neatly folded to you?” he roared. She didn’t know how to respond and just stood there with a hand over the slapped cheek. “Follow instructions or you get punished! Now apologize and do it right!”

Jenny fought to keep from crying. Sarah couldn’t watch and focused on taking off his second sock and balling both of them neatly. “I’m….sorry.” She turned to fold the pants and he stopped her again with a smack on the ass.

“I’m sorry SIR!” he corrected. Sarah couldn’t believe how closely this followed her first night. He definitely had a set ***********. She suddenly wondered if there had been others before her.

Jenny neatly folded the pants and coiled the belt. Sarah waited for her to finish and then she added the socks. They both got back in front of him.

“Kneel and work together.” Once on their knees, they reached up and pulled down either side of his underwear in unison until his dick popped out right between their faces. Jenny’s eyes got wide and Sarah knew exactly how her friend felt. Sarah jumped up and folded the underwear, quickly put it in place on the chair and ran to get back on her knees.

“Suck it one at a time. Sarah first.” Sarah reached up to grab the base and direct the head at her mouth when he stopped her. “Mouth only.”

“Yes sir.” She put her hand back at her side and had to lean down to angle his penis into her mouth. Then she straightened up and started bobbing on his dick. Jenny watched her friend just inches from her face swallow his dick to an impressive depth. Sarah showed off her skills and caught Jenny’s impressed smirk out of the corner of her eye. His shaft glistened with Sarah’s saliva as she picked up her tempo.

“Now Jenny.” Jenny visibly tensed. Sarah pulled back until only the head rested in her mouth and then she leaned toward Jenny. Jenny got the hint and leaned in and put her mouth on the shaft and ran it up toward the head. Sarah shifted to working down the shaft as Jenny slid the head into her mouth. It seemed very coordinated for a first attempt. Sarah continued to work down toward his balls and angled lower while Jenny started to bob on his dick.

She tried to go as deep as Sarah but gagged only halfway down. She had to back off a little but worked to try to duplicate Sarah’s earlier efforts. Sarah couldn’t help but feel a little proud that she seemed better at it than her ‘more experienced’ friend. They switched again several times at his direction. Jenny followed Sarah’s example and licked his balls. Sarah doubted Jenny had ever licked a man’s balls before.

Mr. Michael’s cock stood at full attention when he stopped them and stood them up again. He went to his bag and got his paddle. Jenny paled at the sight of it. “You are both going to have to be punished for stealing. You will have to learn your lesson.” He explained that they were going to be spanked while repeating that they would not steal and would be willing submissives. He warned them to keep their hands forward and to not reach back and advised them to stay loose and breath. Sarah of course had heard the exact same speech. He had her go first again. Obviously, he intended Sarah to show Jenny how to behave for the indoctrination.

He rubbed the paddle over her ass and started spanking slowly. Sarah knew exactly what to expect but didn’t have to play up the pain as getting spanked still hurt but it didn’t bother her as much as that first time. She swore not to steal anymore and pledged to be Mr. Michaels willing slut. She intentionally forgot her ‘sirs’ a couple of times so he could correct her. She finished by counting her last five hard strokes. Her ass had turned a bright pink and she could feel the heat coming off the skin.

Sarah saw Jenny tremble as she laid over his lap. She looked tense and terrified after watching Sarah take such hard spanks. He rubbed the paddle on her ass and warned her again to keep her hands forward and not to try to cover her ass. He started slow but built up to a hard slap. Jenny cried out and Sarah saw tears run down her friend’s cheeks.

He did the other cheek and she reached back instinctively to protect her poor ass from the last big slap. Mr. Michaels only stopped in time. “What did I tell you?! Get that arm up there!” he yelled. She complied but her trembling got worse punctuated by her loud sobs. He grabbed her by the hair and pulled her head around to look at him. “Stop the fucking crying right now, or I’ll double this punishment! You take what I give you and stop the bullshit!” Jenny’s breath hitched while she forced herself to stop crying. The spanking continued.

Sarah wanted to help her, but she also knew he would continue to give Jenny what she deserved, and Sarah reminded herself that Jenny had cheated her too. Jenny pleaded for him to stop and swore she wouldn’t steal again. She didn’t want to say she would be his submissive, but he insisted, and she finally sputtered it out.

“You broke another rule by moving your hand. You will get eight spanks instead of five for failing to do as told. Start counting.” With that, he started with the first strong spank. Jenny counted, struggling to get out the last three. Finally, he finished and allowed her to stand. She looked back and saw her bright pink butt and Sarah knew exactly how hot it would feel to her. She watched Jenny touch her ass gingerly and cringe.

He got his phone out and started a new video. “Now I want to watch you two kiss and rub each other’s asses.” This legitimately took them both by surprise. Sarah had kind of assumed there would probably be some girl-on-girl action, but now she had to face actually doing it. Another first for her. She had never kissed or touched another woman. At least not in passion. She had never even touched another girl’s boobs sexually. Lots of the girls kissed lightly as friends now and then. She had kissed Jenny that way many times. Like when Jenny gave her the purse. But he expected a passionate kiss between lovers. And where it would obviously lead to from there.

She had to accept the fact that she would surely be a lesbian in every sense of the word from that point on. Or at least bisexual. She knew this wouldn’t be completely new to Jenny. Jenny had a couple of experimental nights with girls previously. One girl in particular in the junior class that she had gotten together with after drinking too much. That girl being a confirmed lesbian, only interested in women, had even tried to get Jenny to date her. But Jenny had called it a drunken mistake and declined any deeper relationship. Nevertheless, a couple of months later, she had another ‘drunken mistake’ with the same girl. So Sarah always suspected her friend had some sapphic desires deep down.

Sarah steeled herself and turned to Jenny to obey. She pulled Jenny into her feeling her hard nipples press into Jenny’s breasts. She enjoyed the feel of her soft skin as compared to boy’s rougher exterior. She reached forward and they touched lips. The kiss started slow but gained in strength. Sarah let her tongue run against Jenny’s lips. She got more courageous and tried to part Jenny’s lips. Jenny stayed stiff and tried to resist her advances. Knowing they would both incur his wrath if he thought they held back, Sarah let her hands roam over Jenny’s body and tried again to get Jenny into character.

With Jenny still resisting Sarah’s advances, it didn’t surprise her when Mr. Michaels lowered the phone, grabbed Jenny by the hair at the base of the skull and pulled her away from Sarah. He yanked back on her head forcing Jenny to stare up at him. He grabbed her nipple and squeezed hard between his thumb and forefinger. Sarah knew how hard he pinched and then he started to twist slowly.

Jenny whimpered and issued a meek protest. “You do what I say, when I say, or you will get punished!! Is that understood?!” He glared at her nose to nose. “Or should we just stop all of this and you and your friend can go to jail. Face up to what you have done. Live with the consequences. And get the fuck out!” He waited staring at her.

Jenny panted and continued to whimper. He twisted her nipple even harder. Sarah could see all of the repercussions running across Jenny’s face. Most of all she knew Jenny would regret having to face her father. Still sobbing she blurted out, “I will do it sir. I will kiss her. Whatever you say. Sir. Just please stop. That hurts so much. Sir. Please, I will do anything you say!!” she pleaded.

He let go of her nipple, but held her fast. “Calm down. Now.” Jenny took a deep breath and settled herself. He held her until she had control of herself again. “Let’s try again. Last chance. Start getting it right or we are done.”

He finally let go and Jenny quickly stretched her neck to the side. She moved back to Sarah and embraced her. Jenny started kissing Sarah with a lover’s intent. Her tongue started to explore Sarah’s mouth and she moaned. Her hands rubbed Sarah’s back and lightly gripped her ass, ignoring the fact that she knew Sarah’s ass would be as sore as hers. She even started slowly gyrating her body against Sarah’s, letting their tits rub against each other. Her nipples stiffened and pressed into Sarah.

Sarah let go of any inhibitions and the two girls became true lovers. An urgency broke out between them to make each other feel good. Jenny broke the kiss and reached down and took Sarah’s nipple into her mouth. She sucked it and licked all over. She switched to the other and squeezed them both. She got Sarah moaning at the wonderful feel of Jenny’s soft lips on her tender spots. Jenny’s mouth and technique felt so much softer than most of the boys she had been with. Almost as good as Mr. Michaels himself.

After a minute of enjoying Jenny’s caresses, she pulled Jenny up, kissed her and then reached down and did the same to Jenny. Being her first time to suck on a woman’s breasts, she started a little tentatively, but quickly got into it. She sucked hard on the nipple and liked the feel of its instant response. She nibbled and teased it. Jenny responded as well throwing her head back and telling Sarah how good it felt. Sarah started lightly squeezing and twisting Jenny’s other nipple next, and Jenny groaned with pleasure.

“Jenny, put Sarah on the edge of the bed and go down on her.” Jenny’s hands held Sarah’s sides and helped her up into position. Sarah opened her legs and leaned back on her elbows. Jenny kissed from Sarah’s neck, down between her breasts, across her stomach and down her right thigh. She kneeled on one knee and worked back up the inner thigh. Sarah bent her legs at the knee and planted her feet on the edge of the bed so that her legs opened even farther.

Sarah could feel Jenny’s breath blow over her wet pussy and felt a shiver down her spine. Jenny reached out and kissed and then gently licked the outer labia. She continued to do that in long strokes getting deeper and deeper into the folds. Finally, she started at the bottom and in one long stroke, plunged her tongue into the slit and worked up to the clit. Sarah moaned. It felt delicious. She felt completely turned on, especially knowing the sensations blooming from her womanhood had been brought on by her long term friend’s tongue, making the whole scene both naughty and wrong in such a good way.

“No cumming Sarah. You are not allowed to have an orgasm. If you cum, you get punished. Say it.”

“Yes sir, I won’t cum. Or I’ll get punished. I promise, sir.” She grabbed her knees and forced her legs open a little more and tried to relax. Following orders would be difficult as Jenny’s skillful tongue twirled around her clit and her tummy already started twitching.

“Jenny, if you don’t make her cum, then you will be the one to get punished. I want to hear her shake from an orgasm. Quickly.” He had intentionally pitted them against one another. Someone would get spanked again. Jenny’s quick increase in tempo clearly showed Sarah that she had no intention of being the one to get the punishment. She dug in deeper, fucking Sarah’s pussy with her tongue. Her tongue curled and pushed in and out as deep as she could go. Sarah’s moans picked up and she felt her legs shake. Her pussy became a well spring of warmth and lubricating juices. Jenny went back to lashing Sarah’s clit fast and soft like a hummingbird’s wing. Sarah clenched and struggled to hold off a growing climax. Her passionate exclamations only encouraged her friend.

Jenny brought her fingers up, but before she could sink them into Sarah’s tight twat, Mr. Michaels ordered, “Tongue only.” He got extreme close ups of the action with his phone in many different angles. He focused on each girl’s face to capture the rapture of the moment. Neither girl really noticed. Then he warned, “Two minutes left.”

Jenny redoubled her efforts to force the orgasm out of her friend. Jenny sucked Sarah’s clit into her mouth. The tip of her tongue dug into and pressed hard into Sarah’s pleasure center making the sensation incredibly intense. Sarah panted and felt sweat spring out on her forehead. She twisted her own nipples hard, pulling on them trying to distract herself. Her whole body shuddered and shook as she threw her head from side to side furiously holding back the wave of orgasm that wanted to claim her. She resigned herself to giving in when Mr. Michaels called time. Jenny didn’t stop at first continued to suck on Sarah’s clit, refusing to lose.

“I said STOP. Right now.” He spanked Jenny’s ass with the paddle three times hard. Jenny yelped and let go and dropped her head in pain. She had lost. “Switch spots.”

The girls helped each other change positions. Sarah leaned in to give Jenny a warm lingering kiss. Despite not getting to cum, the cunnilingus had felt wonderful, and she hoped her friend understood that she enjoyed it. Mr. Michaels told them the same rules applied.

Sarah broke the kiss and nuzzled into Jenny’s neck, peppering her with small light kisses worked her way down. She let her tongue run over the skin from her neck, over her breast, taking time to nibble on her nipple, and down toward her navel. She pulled back only long enough to blow on the moistened skin to make the trail come alive on her skin and got a coo from Jenny in response. She circled her navel and felt Jenny’s tummy flutter.

Sarah had butterflies in her own stomach and she kissed lower until she came face to face with another woman’s pussy. Her nose brushed through the pubic hair and Sarah could smell the heady scent of a woman up close for the first time. The dark hair framed the tight lips that glistened with moisture elicited by the night’s events. Her engorged clit hood stood out and she could see the small button trying to peek out. Her own mouth watered in preparation for her first taste of vagina.

She took a deep breath, closed her eyes, and leaned forward to kiss Jenny in a more private way than she ever thought she would. She started like Jenny with long strokes over the labia. The taste hit her immediately. A soft tang with a slightly sweet flavor. She had tasted herself on Mr. Michaels dick and even off her own fingers on a few occasions, but she noticed the different flavor of Jenny. She immediately liked it and knew that her sex life would change forever from that moment on.

She continued with soft swirls around the clit barely touching it. The soft pubic hair wetted with a combination of her saliva and Jenny’s juices coated her nose. Sarah bit down on some of the hair and pulling on the pussy skin to lightly stretch it. Jenny moaned and Sarah felt Jenny’s leg muscles tighten. Sarah spread the pussy lips and dug in deep with her tongue. She sucked on her clit and twisted it lightly. Jenny’s pussy started to grind and she called out to her friend in a stream of sexy expletives, begging her not to stop. “Oh fuck, you are going to make me cum,” she grunted lost in the moment.

For a first timer, Sarah seemed to know instinctively what to do. Another minute of unbelievable torture and Jenny started to shake on the brink. Then Sarah did it. She followed Jenny’s example and started fucking her friends pussy with her tongue curled up. She slammed her face into her pussy and felt pussy juice coat her face. With her tongue embedded as deep as she could reach, Sarah used her nose to bat Jenny’s clit from side to side.

Jenny couldn’t take it and threw her head back as her body began to orgasm. She screamed out her intent, clearly lost in the moment. The orgasm went on and on lasting over thirty seconds. She moaned and her pelvis pressed harder into Sarah’s face. Her only words a mixture of ‘Oh my god’ and ‘Fuck fuck fuck’. She continued to shiver in the afterglow even after Sarah released her pussy from her clutches and moved up to give Jenny a cum soaked kiss. Jenny greedily licked Sarah’s lips.

Mr. Michaels pulled back and set the phone down. “Looks like Jenny is going to need some more training. But we will deal with that later. Along with her punishment for failing to follow instructions. Time for me to try this pussy for myself.”

He went over and got the camera on the tripod with the light and put it at the far middle side of the bed. He got on the bed and laid down in the middle and indicated the girls to join him, one on either side. They each sidled up on either side of him with their hands draped on his chest and rested their heads on his arms. He smiled and looked at each of them. “My beautiful blonde and brunette 18-year-olds. My willing sex kittens. I could get used to this.”

With that, he kissed first Jenny and then Sarah. The kisses were passionate and soft. Sarah kissed his chest while he kissed Jenny and Jenny kissed his neck while he kissed Sarah. Sarah’s earlier jealousy had evaporated and she felt oddly comforted having Jenny there to experience all of this with her. Jenny still showed the telltale signs of post-orgasmic afterglow of her face.

He moved Jenny up to sit over his cock. She reached down and inserted it and slowly slid herself down on it. She let out a satisfied moan and started fucking herself on him. Mr. Michaels moved Sarah up over his face, facing Jenny. His tongue started to work her pussy.

Her body had been left wanting from her earlier denial. Her tummy churned as she ground against him and felt his nose work in and out of her folds. His tongue knew exactly where to go on her clit and how to treat it. He leaned back enough to tell the girls to kiss before going back to teasing her clit. Jenny and Sarah leaned together and kissed in a sexual triangle, groping and petting each other’s tits.

Jenny ground her clit forward and backward against his pelvis in a small circle, making the head of his dick swirl in her pussy. Sarah reached her mouth down and sucked on Jenny’s nipple, biting it hard between her teeth. Jenny let go with her second orgasm, pulling Sarah’s head firmly into her pliant mammary.

Before Jenny’s orgasm had finished, Sarah gave into Mr. Michaels assault of her clit with a muffled cry as Jenny held her against her breast. She moaned and her pelvis trembled against his mouth. She felt him lapping at her pussy, guessing she had leaked profusely into his mouth. She never let go of Jenny’s nipple. As both girl’s orgasms subsided, he put Sarah on her hands and knees and had Jenny lay down in front of her. He fucked Sarah doggie style while she ate Jenny’s pussy.

Next, he put Jenny on her side and scissor fucked her while she lay with her head resting on one of Sarah’s thighs with Sarah grinding her pussy into her face. They went through a bunch of positions, but each with him fucking one girl while that girl ate the other girl’s pussy. He finally came in Jenny while the two girls were in a 69 with Sarah on the bottom and him fucking Jenny right over her face.

When he pulled out after cumming deep in Jenny, he watched and made sure the camera caught the white goo slide out of her pussy into Sarah’s waiting mouth and Sarah slurping down all of it before aggressively seeking the rest with her tongue darting into the gaping hole. Jenny stayed focused on Sarah’s pussy, teasing her clit while finger fucking her with two fingers to another welcome release.

Ready for a break, he told the girls to run downstairs to grab them drinks. As soon as the girls were out of earshot, they started to whisper. Jenny started, “What are we going to do? How do we get out of this?”

“I don’t think we can Jenny. We either be his whores, or we go to jail.”

“We wouldn’t go to jail. No way. My dad would get a lawyer. There must be a way out.”

“Maybe you can afford a lawyer, but I can’t. We committed a felony, Jenny. You can’t just walk away from that.”

“I don’t know. Maybe we could still claim he molested us. That he forced us.”

“Look, do you really want to take a chance? With those videos of us saying we wanted to be his prostitutes. Offering sex for money? How the hell would we get out of it when he shows that? And what would your parents say when they saw that? Do you still think they would come to your rescue? We’d be fucked. We might even get arrested for prostitution.”

“Yeah, but….but….there has to be something we can do.” Jenny visibly reeled as the thoughts hit her. All of the implications of everything that had happened. Hopelessness spread over her face.

“Look, I know how scared you are of your dad. He would kill you if this got out. Maybe even disown you. Think about it. Videos of you stealing. Videos of you offering to be a whore. Videos of you and I fucking each other. And videos of us fucking him. Obviously willingly.” She shook her head. “We have no choice but to just do what he says and live with it.”

They were standing in the kitchen and had three beers in their hands. “We’ve already taken too long. I don’t know about you, but I sure as hell don’t want to be spanked again.” Jenny agreed and they ran back up the stairs and to the bedroom before slowing down and walking in.

“That took a while,” he said as they walked in.

“Sorry sir. I had to pee really quick,” Sarah covered instinctively. She handed him one of the beers and they all took long drinks. Mr. Michaels luckily didn’t pursue it anymore and told them to get back on the bed. He wanted a blow job and he wanted the girls to take turns. He indicated Jenny should start.

Jenny got between his legs and started sucking his dick. She had her hand on his shaft and started stroking while quickly bobbing her head. She went right at it.

Mr. Michaels stopped her and told Sarah to take over. Jenny looked concerned and a little hurt that he stopped her after such a short time. Sarah leaned down and licked and played with him She twirled her tongue around the head and kissed it. After a minute or so, Mr. Michaels commented, “that’s much better Sarah. Teach Jenny how to give a better blow job. You seem more experienced.” He said it with a little smile liking his own joke.

Sarah explained how she found it better to start slow and to tease him first. And the importance of keeping eye contact while she played with him. She told her to use lots of saliva and to stroke up over the head since it had the most feeling. She sucked his balls into her mouth and played with them. She demonstrated every move he had taught her. Then she held his cock out and told her to try.

Jenny did everything Sarah showed her. She could see that Mr. Michaels responded to her improved technique. Sarah took back over and showed her the next steps as he started to get more excited, demonstrating how to use her hand and mouth together, working to take the cock deeper and deeper into her mouth all the way to the back of her throat. Mr. Michaels showed signs of getting close and she had Jenny take over. Jenny struggled to get the cock as deep into her mouth and gagged a couple of times, but fought through it and kept stroking as fast and deep as she could go.

“I’m going to cum Jenny. Don’t stop. I want you to swallow all of my cum. If any spills, you are going to clean it up.” Jenny’s eyes tried to find Sarah in panic, but she didn’t stop. Sarah knew from their many talks about sexual encounters that Jenny always spit. She had commented on hating the taste and the thought of having to swallow a boy’s spunk made her want to puke.

He let loose and exploded into her mouth. She tried to swallow but completely panicked and lost all concentration. She choked and all of the cum slipped out of her mouth, down his dick, into his pubic hair and even onto his stomach. She choked with strings of cum and saliva hanging down from her mouth.

She looked up at him and said, “Sorry, I choked. I didn’t mean to do that.”

“Sorry SIR!” he reminded her sternly.

“Sorry sir,” she repeated and looked worried with her hands and mouth still full of mess. She didn’t know what to do.

He stared at her for a minute with a frown. Finally he said, “Well?? I told you to swallow or clean it up!”

Jenny started to get up and go get a rag to clean up. “No you dumb slut. Clean it up WITH YOUR MOUTH. Lick this mess up!” he bellowed. Jenny stared at him like a deer in the headlights. She looked at the mess and then at Sarah. His instructions had been clear, but the thought of what he demanded clearly disgusted her.

“Sarah. Show her.” Without complaint or even a pause, Sarah first licked the strings off of Jenny’s face and mouth. Then she turned and moved down and started running her tongue through the goo on his stomach, sucking it up into her mouth. “That’s how you do it Jenny. Now help your friend. Or should I get the paddle again. I won’t be as gentle this time.” Jenny’s eyes popped.

She dropped down and started licking his dick. The two girls lapped away. Jenny crinkled her nose and dry heaved several times as she forced it down. Within a minute or two, they had it all up and Mr. Michaels looked pretty clean. The worst for Jenny had been getting it out of his pubic hair. It got all tangled and she had to work at sucking it out of the hair. Finally she sat back. Her hands were still a mess. “Every drop!”

Jenny stared at him with hate in her eyes and then glanced at Sarah looking for support. Seeing none, she started licking and sucking on her fingers. She also ran her tongue around her lips getting any final remnants. She looked sick to her stomach.

Finally, he seemed to relax. He kissed Sarah deeply and thanked her for being a good instructor. “With a little practice, I think Jenny can be a great cocksucker.” Jenny seemed insulted by the comment but didn’t say anything in her defense.

“Okay, both of you bring me your phones. Then take the camera into bathroom and set it up outside the shower. You two clean up. I want you to use lots of soap and then suck each other’s cunts. Use the shower wand to get each other off. Don’t come back out here until you have both gotten off. Go. And no dawdling this time. If you are not back here with those phones in one minute, I’m getting the paddle again.”

Both girls jumped down and ran to the stairs. They didn’t talk and focused on the task. The threat of the paddle seemed all too real. They retrieved their phones and ran back. Both were panting a little. He got their codes and told them to go shower. Sarah grabbed the camera and tripod and got it set up. The girls got in shower and turned it on. Jenny whispered, “That was disgusting. How the hell did you know all that about giving bjs? Do you actually like the taste?” Sarah got some soap and started to rub some on her friend.

“I don’t know, just practice, I guess. And I don’t think cum tastes that bad. I guess I’m kinda used to it. It gets easier every time I swallow a load.” Her nonchalant comment clearly stunned Jenny. Sarah knew Jenny had always fancied herself as the being the bigger slut between the two of them. But Sarah’s comments and demonstration clearly showed Jenny a side of Sarah that she didn’t know existed.

“Let’s concentrate on this so we don’t get into trouble. I don’t want him to hear us whispering on the video.” With that, she turned Jenny to the camera lens and started to rub soap all over her tits from behind. She pinched the slippery nipples as they popped out between her fingers. Before long, they were both moaning and getting into it. They rubbed each other’s clits. Sarah started to wonder why they hadn’t been doing this for years. It felt so good. She pushed Jenny up against the shower wall and dropped between her legs. She attacked Jenny’s pussy and slid her first two fingers into her cunt. She remembered how Mr. Michaels did it and curled her fingers and stroked her g-spot. Jenny’s moans grew louder as the warm water splashed over them.

Jenny dropped down and took a turn being the protagonist. She got behind Sarah and bent Sarah forward with her face a few feet from the camera. She spread her legs and alternated between sticking her tongue into her pussy and then her fingers. Sarah started to feel the edges of climax build within her. The number of times she normally had orgasms during sex would have seemed crazy a few months prior. She had become a sex starved slut, craving the wonderful release of an orgasm all the time. Sexual fantasies occupied most of her thoughts. And now those fantasies would include women as well as men.

She stopped Jenny and grabbed the wand. She turned the top to a massage setting, sending out the water in a fast pulse. She played it over Jenny’s pussy and she screamed out, “Oh fuck! That is so intense. Oh my god!” Within two minutes, Jenny came hard, falling back against the wall for support. Sarah could see the pulsing water had made her clit swell and turn a deep red from the hard strumming. Sarah leaned forward and kissed the tender bud, making Jenny jump at the over stimulation. Jenny pushed her friend away and grabbed the wand.

Jenny switched places with Sarah and pointed the wand at Sarah’s slit. Sarah knew other girls that had talked about masturbating this way, but she had never tried it. The hard pulse of the warm water on her tender genitals made Sarah jump. Jenny put a hand on her stomach and pushed her back against the wall and told Sarah to spread her legs wider. The water played over her labia and returned time and time again to her exposed clitoris. It felt different than anything that had touched her there.

Her legs felt weak as her body shook from the power of the orgasm that the water pulled from her. Without anything else to hold onto, she grabbed Jenny’s head. Without knowing she had even done it, she pulled Jenny to her pussy and forced her mouth onto her throbbing clit. Jenny obliged and slowly circled the nub with the tip of her tongue and batted at it. The orgasm bought on by the water hadn’t even finished when another wave of pleasure shook her body again. Another new type of orgasm. She opened her eyes feeling the flush fill her face and saw Mr. Michaels standing behind the camera taking it all in. He had lust in his eyes and he winked at Sarah.

They dried off and all went back into the bedroom. Mr. Michaels asked them to pose, and he took a bunch of pictures. Many of them close ups. All in sexy and provocative positions. Some individual and some together.

Then Mr. Michaels gave them their phones back and then recited the same rules he had given Sarah the first time. No talking to anyone except each other, always wear rubbers and always address him as ‘sir’. He told them he still hadn’t decided their punishment for Jenny cumming during their duel. Sarah wanted to protest that she had followed instructions but knew it to be pointless. He had given them opposing instructions. They were going to fail no matter what. He clearly wanted to remind them that they were in this together, not apart.

“Is everything understood?”

“Yessir,” they said in unison and then looked at each other and smiled.

He paid them and gave them a tip. He told them that they could keep the money they had stolen, but to be careful not to spend too much too fast. They didn’t want anyone wondering why they suddenly had a bunch of cash. He kissed them both and gave them both another squeeze and then told them to get going and he would be in touch.

They got dressed and drove off for home. They hadn’t said anything since heading downstairs. Then Jenny said, “We fucked each other.” It hung there for a minute and then they both got the giggles. “And we are sex slaves. To an old man.” They started laughing so hard, Sarah had tears coming down her cheeks. The ridiculousness of the night had made them giddy and slap happy. “How they hell did that all happen tonight?”

“I don’t know. It is crazy. That was just so much for one night.”

“I mean, I don’t want to be trapped like this, but that was all pretty hot tonight, right?” Jenny ventured.

“I had so many orgasms. I thought I was going to explode,” Sarah confirmed.

“But my ass is still so sore!” Jenny shifted in her seat to reiterate her comment.

“Mine too. That hurt like hell!”

“He scares the shit out of me!”

“Me too.”

“So what do we do?” Jenny asked.

Sarah thought about it for a minute. “I really don’t think there is anything we can do. We’re screwed. Just follow his instructions and try to keep him from getting upset again. Maybe it won’t be all bad?” She said the last as a question because it really was a question. What did the future hold? Sarah knew Jenny would have some tough challenges ahead. Harder than she could imagine. But she wasn’t in any better of a situation. She knew Mr. Michaels would keep coming up with crazier things for her to do. Gang bangs. Running through the night naked. Butt plugs and anal sex. What would he do next?

---